Critiques ~It's come to my attention...

... that people comment differently on the artwork they see lately. They don't make constructive critiques to help their fellow artists like they used to. I received several comments to improve my artwork when I first joined DA. Now, all I get is a "wow I really like that" response (not that I don't like that type of response), and if someone doesn't like what I have made, they usually don't comment on it at all (which is also fine). However, I am not just referring to my own work, but the work of everyone here on DA. I am sure there are some people out there who are making good critique comments still, but I rarely see them anymore.

I have seen some good critiques, and some down-right bad ones. Perhaps it's just that people don't know how to critique without seeming to be rude. First off, if the artist has it set to recieve advanced-critique comments, then you have permission to tell the artist what you see as 'off' in their artwork. Just keep in mind these things:

1. Point out something that you like about the artwork first. Talk about why you like it. It's not really fair to just jump into a post with the negative aspects of their artwork. You don't want to appear as though you're only out to make them look bad.

2. Tell the artist what you believe to be wrong or out of place and (this is important) how to correct it. Do not just say, "Oh the eyes look strange to me." and leave it at that. Get descriptive, "Your eyes look good, but they would look better if you made the pupils a little bigger. It would make your figure appear more alive."

3. Add in the rest of the things you like about the artwork and why you like them. If you think they did a good job, let them know!

You need to think of critiquing from both sides. Read over your post before submitting it! Is this what you would be happy with reading if it were directed to you or would you feel offended by reading it? What could you change or add to make it more helpful and friendly rather than just simply a post pointing out mistakes?

The main reason for critiques is to learn. It is good for the artist to have critiques on their own art so they know what to improve on in later pieces, but it is also good for the critiquer. By looking at the artwork endepth, you are training your eye to notice the proportions, color, composition, and other aspects of artwork.. all things that will help you on your own art! If you're unsure how to get your thoughts across about someone else's art, don't forget you can always grab a book for help. There are so many books out there on art, I am sure you can find something to help you get your thoughts across.. and I'll bet you will learn a few new things on the way too.

Well, I am off to go visit [link] and talk to some of the artists! They are having an arts and crafts festival today and tomorrow in Norfolk, Virginia. If you're in the area you should go check them out and support your local arts and crafters!

~Nanilli~